Reinventing the Returns Process: A Strategic Approach for Retailers

An image of a package being handed from person delivery driver.

As e-commerce continues to grow, so does the rate of product returns. Retailers are now faced with the challenge of managing returns in a way that enhances customer experience while maintaining profitability.

The Rising Tide of Returns

Online retail purchases have a higher return rate compared to in-store purchases. As e-commerce continues to gain a larger share of overall retail commerce, returns are set to increase. This presents a significant challenge for brands and stores, as the returns process is a crucial part of the customer experience (CX). Businesses are now seeking ways to turn this process into a competitive advantage. However, the task of satisfying customer demands while preserving profits and operational efficiency is a delicate balancing act.

Understanding the Returns Landscape

American consumers are known for their propensity to return purchased goods, with a return rate of 14.5% in 2023. This behavior is particularly prevalent in online clothing purchases, where customers often buy multiple sizes, styles, and colors to try on at home. For retailers, the return of online purchases presents a two-fold problem: transportation costs for returned items and the inability to immediately resell returned goods.

Rethinking the Returns Strategy

Retailers have responded to this challenge in various ways, including charging customers for returns or banning repeat offenders. However, these approaches do not enhance CX and can lead to reputational damage. A more strategic approach involves handling returns intelligently, focusing on reducing costs and inconvenience while improving the customer experience.

Leveraging Data for Efficient Returns Management

Data plays a crucial role in managing returns effectively. By understanding customer behavior and identifying problem areas, retailers can customize their returns process. For instance, they can identify customers who abuse the returns policy or flag items that are returned more frequently, indicating potential quality control issues.

Balancing Profitability and Customer Satisfaction

As more retailers charge for returns, they can use strategies to maintain customer satisfaction. For example, offering bonus credits for free exchanges or using the return process as an opportunity for additional sales. The key is to maintain the customer relationship while continuously seeking ways to make it profitable.

Enhancing Sustainability and Reducing Waste

An intelligent returns process can also contribute to sustainability and waste reduction, aspects that consumers increasingly demand from retailers. By providing options to ship returned items directly to donation or recycling centers, retailers can reduce their carbon footprint.

Improving Product Information

Retailers can also reduce the need for returns by improving product information on their websites. Providing detailed information about clothing fit and showing products on different body types can help customers make more informed purchasing decisions, reducing the need for “bracketing.”

As the retail landscape continues to evolve, the focus should not just be on the point of sale but on the entire customer journey. By adopting a strategic approach to managing returns, retailers can enhance customer experience, maintain profitability, and contribute to sustainability.